NEWS
Beast Wreaks Havoc in Margaretville... in 1895
On July 29, 1895, William Cook of Margaretville, NY, engaged in a "hand-to-hand fight" with a "ferocious ape-like being" that residents claimed had been devouring their "horses, sheep, and cattle," and splitting their bones to eat the marrow. As reported by the New York Herald on July 30, 1895, the beast threw Cook twenty feet and "nearly killed him." "The monster is the most energetic summer man, if he is a man, that has ever visited these parts," the Herald wrote. Peter Thomas, "who is neither weak-willed nor a doubter," described a terrifying encounter in which, while driving a team of horses, "a horrible monster" "brandishing long and hairy arms" leaped from the underbrush, letting out a "raucous, inarticulate cry," before jumping high into the air, breaking a horse's neck, tearing it from the harness and dragging the corpse into the woods. The other horse reportedly "tore into the village." The shaken Thomas, "a truthful man, as everyone who knows him is willing to vouch," was taken to a public house, where, "under the stimulus of restoratives," was able to recount his harrowing encounter.
Now, unfortunately, as the Herald makes clear, men, real men, "are scarce" in the summer resort town of Margaretville. In fact, some of the women, "inclined to be flippant," suggested that the monster would be in high demand "if invited to the next hop." Fortunately, plucky "bands of youths" in "duck trousers and blue coats" teamed up with local farmers to corner this lady-stealing bachelor of a beast in its lair. Peter Thomas led the hunting party. The emasculated and irate men and their duck-trousered youths located the beast's lair in a clearing roughly two miles from Margaretville proper. While they did not locate the monster, their discovery left them rattled. "In the centre of the space there were smoldering embers of a big fire," wrote the Herald. "Around it were half gnawed bones of sheep and cattle and part of the remains of Mr. Thomas' unfortunate horse." One of the farmers stated that in his "forty years as a man and boy he had never seen anything so 'weirdlike' before."
The men headed home, no doubt to the disappointed women of the village. Farmer John Cook was returning home alone that evening when the mysterious, hairy heartthrob leaped from nowhere and attacked him! Cook fired his gun, but claimed the bullets seemed to have no effect on the "wild man," whom he described as being roughly "seven feet tall, entirely nude, covered with black hair, with a long beard and with teeth which project from his mouth like fangs." John Cook was ultimately thrown twenty feet, just like William Cook, and the residents of Margaretville were left to ponder whether they would have the right to shoot the beast, for fear that they would be tried for murder if it turned out to indeed be a man. A tall, hairy, sinewy man.