New Ownership for American Hotel

Sharon Springs - The beloved American Hotel in Sharon Springs, NY is now under new ownership! This quaint and well known bed & breakfast with restaurant and bar has been purchased by Michael Palaia and Marco Braeutigam who have “embarked on a mission to carry forward Doug and Garth’s vision, delivering an exceptional boutique hotel and restaurant experience”.

In an exclusive interview with Michael, he offered, “there won’t be abrupt changes, but there will be some upgrades, including a brand new kitchen.” The couple have recently moved from Tranquility, NJ, for this opportunity and said, “it really felt right from the beginning”. The process started Memorial Day in 2024 and though there were some delays in closing, the sale is final and the American Hotel will continue on.

Bringing 40 years of Hospitality experience to the table, Palaia is no stranger to this business. After a few projects are completed, the new owners look forward to welcoming guests back to this historic location for overnight stays in March and then the exciting reopening of the restaurant & bar to follow in April. 

As many of you may know, this *hotel* was originally *built in 1840 by Nicholas LaRue and was* purchased by the late Doug Plummer and Garth Roberts in 1996 after it had been abandoned for nearly 30 years.. Following an extensive five-year renovation, the American Hotel proudly reopened its doors on May 23, 2001. Doug and Garth played an integral role in the Sharon Springs community with Doug serving as Village Mayor from 2013 until his death in December 2023. This hotel has been a beloved getaway, hosting numerous special events throughout the years.

With large shoes to fill, Michael and Marco are ready for this next step and understand the importance of the hotel’s history, particularly the successful last 24 seasons under the previous owners. The American Hotel will continue to be a cherished destination and cornerstone of the community, offering a blend of historical charm and modern amenities. 

Under this new ownership, the American Hotel remains a testament to the Village of Sharon Springs’ revitalization and will always remain a favorite spot for visitors and locals seeking a historical and memorable experience. Please join me in welcoming new American Hotel Owners, Michael Palaia and Marco Braeutigam to Sharon Springs! Look out for more updates to come!