NEWS
No Shortage of Financial Headaches for Schoharie County
SCHOHARIE COUNTY — Sobering would be one good word to describe discussions on the 2027 Schoharie County Budget.
A projected property tax increase in the tentative county budget for next year is still 24.23 percent, county Administrator Bryan Best reported at a Board of Supervisors public hearing on the budget on Monday morning, Nov. 9.
This came after Best, the Finance Committee and others worked to reduce the increase from 36.1 percent when Best first presented the tentative budget last month. Since that time, county officials have decided to use $2 million in fund balance (surplus) instead of the $1 million proposed in October and are also projecting an additional $600,000 in sales tax revenue that can be applied to the $126 million 2027 tentative budget.
The outlook remains far from rosy.
"The Finance Committee knows that (proposed tax increase) is still too high," Best said. "We will continue to work."
Best said he has gone over the tentative budget line by line with county department heads looking for savings and there's a fairly good chance the situation might force cuts in personnel.
"You're talking about positions already occupied?" BOS Vice-Chairman Donald Airey asked.
"Yes, I am," Best responded. "I don't think we get to where we need to be unless we're looking at people in the chair."
Several Supervisors weighed in on the county's rather dire financial straits at the Nov. 9 meeting.
"I think there are areas in the highway budget that can be trimmed," said William M. Smith III of Broome. "I think we should be looking to privatize more of that operation. There would be less overhead, less equipment costs."
Best was receptive to that idea.
"I would love to move toward contracting more stuff out if we can," he said.
Supervisor Ben Oevering of Schoharie said it's time for the county to make major changes in the way it operates.
"The thing we have to do, maybe not this year, is make structural changes in the way we do business," he said. "Without that, we won't get this to a place where it's sustainable. This will only get worse in the next couple of years without structural changes in the way we do business."
Oevering mentioned shared services and more privatization as two possible ways to go.
"Just because we say we will privatize something doesn't necessarily mean it will be cheaper," Supervisor Earl VanWormer of Esperance noted. "There would have to be a hard look at whether it would really be a cost benefit or end up costing more."
County BOS Chairman Bill Federice said "we should look at it (more privatization) for sure but keep in mind, our people are paid less than what contractors pay their people."
Supervisor Roger Gural of Summit said county, municipal and school district taxes are all trending up— often steeply— and he worried about how much residents will be able to manage.
"Most disturbing is that even with all the new economic development, we're not going to close the gap," Airey said. "I don't see us getting ahead of the curve. It's depressing, but it's the hard reality."
He asked Best whether, if the county "bit the bullet" and adopted a 2027 budget with a tax increase of 20 percent or more, whether that would mean it could get back to normal in subsequent years with tax hikes of around 2 or 3 percent a year.
"I'd hope so, but I can't really say definitively that would be the case," Best responded.
He added the county is deferring the purchase of a new ambulance and some building maintenance to beyond 2027 in an effort to save some money. Best stated rising personnel cost— salaries, benefits, retirement costs— is one of the key reasons the county now finds itself in the current financial position.
"We have to change, but probably that change won't come fast. It will take time," Supervisor Werner Hampel of Cobleskill said.
Best said the county's unassigned fund balance (surplus) stood at $21.7 million at the start of this year.
"That's right around where it should be considering the size of our budget," he noted.
When Federice asked what the next steps will be, Supervisor and Finance Committee Chairman Alex Luniewski said more hard work.
"We will come back with options A, B and C, and I don't think any of them will be pretty," Luniewski stated.
Best said it's possible but unlikely the Board of Supervisors would adopt the 2027 budget at the next regular meeting on Nov. 20. The more likely scenario would be adoption at a special meeting in early December or the regular Dec. 18 meeting, though Best said it would be better to adopt the budget before Dec. 18. The deadline is Dec. 20.
In other business from the Nov. 9 meeting, the BOS decided to postpone until the Nov. 20 meeting a public hearing on another six-month moratorium on the use of Biosolids in the county. Supervisor and Agricultural Committee Chair Alicia Terry said a special counsel is working on stronger language in the new Local Law that would impose the moratorium.
The BOS also decided to hold off a little while longer on a new Local Law allowing the county to exceed the state cap of 2 percent on next year's tax increase. It seems pretty much inevitable at this point that the tax increase will be significantly more than 2 percent.
Pictured: Schoharie County Administrator Bryan Best updates the Board of Supervisors on the tentative 2027 county budget.