Tomato Tomahto
Restaurants and Bars

Tomato Tomahto

520 Main St, Margaretville, NY 12455

(551) 220-8485

hello@tomato-tomahto.com

Facebook | Instagram | Yelp | Google Reviews | Book a Table (Resos) | Order with Cashapp | Great Western Catskills

Italian diner and bakery

Offering sandwiches on house baked focaccia, breakfast, sweet pastries, pasta, wine, and Neapolitan style pizza. The Neapolitan style pizza is cooked in a woodfired oven at 850F!

For sweets, the cheesecake, maritozzi and bombolone have been top sellers. Lunch items are a hit, but we’ve heard some favorites are the Il Boss/prosciutto sandwich, chicken parm and pizza.

Open Monday & Friday 11am-8pm, Saturday & Sunday 9am-8pm

Menus

7 views